Q&A with Harry Leslie Smith, author of 1923: A Memoir: Lies and Testaments
In Harry Leslie Smith’s engrossing memoir, 1923: A Memoir: Lies and Testaments, he examines his life in post World War I Britain, growing up and surviving during a time of poverty and social upheaval. It is a story told with wit and soul. I was personally moved by it and was very pleased that Mr. Smith agreed to answer questions about his work and life.
tCR: Thanks for taking the time to respond to these questions. I’d first like to ask you, how hard was it to write about such an emotionally wrenching time of your life?
HLS: It was an incredibly difficult undertaking. For most of my adult life, I repressed my past suffering and tried to erase it from my consciousness. Unfortunately, the past whether it has been kind or cruel to you has a way of dogging you throughout your life. After the death of my wife ten years ago and then the recent death of my middle son; it was necessary for me to fully accept and understand the events which made me the man I am today.
tCR: Was it difficult to remain objective or was that a concern?
HLS: It was very difficult to remain objective while writing this book. It took seven drafts and I am still not completely satisfied with my portrayal of my family’s past.
tCR: Did you have any concerns about writing about your family and how they would perceive the book?
HLS: I think anyone who sets out to write about their family is going to have concerns about how their relatives may perceive a book about their ancestors. I was fortunate, in one sense, that most of the people I describe in 1923 have been dead a long time. Over all, what is left of my family has been supportive of my book.
tCR: You weave the details of world history into your narrative so easily. Are you a history buff?
HLS: I am a history buff and I thought when I set out to write 1923 that it was necessary to include historical context to my early life. I believe it gives the reader a better understanding of my family’s decent into poverty. I also wanted to frame my experiences in the Second World War within the larger historical picture occurring all around me. I also believe that the times spent with my father pouring over that illustrated encyclopaedia as a boy developed my love of history.
tCR: Were you inspired by anything in particular to write your memoir? Are there any memoirs that you have read that inspired you?
HLS: As I mentioned, previously, writing 1923 was a catharsis for me. I needed to take all of those haunting episodes of my early days and put them into an historical perspective as a means to accept both my accomplishments and my many limitations as a human being. I can think of three memoirs that have moved me in indifferent ways. (Siegfried) Sassoon’s Memoirs Of A Fox-Hunting Man because it is about a world lost to the poet through the destruction of the First World War. (Arthur) Koestler’s Arrow In The Blue
which is just an exciting read through the author’s early life. It is all bravado with only small glimpses of the real man behind the curtain. Finally, I would have to say Jung Chang’s Wild Swans : Three Daughters of China
which has some of the most poignant descriptions and emotions of a society destroyed by China’s Cultural Revolution.
tCR: Did you revisit any of your childhood places while writing this book?
HLS: I have returned to some of the places I resided in as a child. I even managed to make a trip back to the bleak farm house on the moor where we lived after my father was forced from our family. I had other members of my family with me and pretended to be quite upbeat. When I was back in my hotel room I wept over those horrible days. The pub is even still around, although it has been converted into condos. The mine has long since closed. The whole village of Barley Hole was buried in slag when the pit closed but the pub was spared.
tCR: How did you become a writer?
HLS: I started writing in the RAF and kept a journal throughout my service and afterwards in Britain. I have been writing for years but I think I am somewhat like the businessman in the Thomas Mann short story who never had the courage or discipline to display his talents because he feared both financial loss and humiliation.
tCR: Other than writing, what else is a passion for you?
HLS: Travel, Tai Chi, gardening, and social justice
tCR: After reflecting on your life so carefully, do you think that Britain has done more now to alleviate the suffering of poverty?
HLS: Great Britain has come along in alleviating the poverty I experienced in my youth. At this very moment, I think Britain, in fact the whole developed world, is turning its back on fighting poverty for short term goals. It seems to me one thing Britain has not alleviated and made worse is the hopelessness many young people feel today. I think this hopelessness comes from feeling trapped by educational cut backs which prevent both financial and emotional advancement. And I also think they are becoming increasing alienated because our society rewards narcissism over introspection. What Britain needs and we never got was a politician like FDR who understood people crave hope and they require jobs to build that hope in themselves.
tCR: I understand you are working on another book. Can you tell us what it is?
HLS: Yes, it is called The Empress of Australia and about my life in post war Germany and my return to Yorkshire. Some of the characters from the first book are in it including my mother and sister. Empress of Australia also introduces new characters and deals with different challenges I encountered. I can say that people will find me in the new book a little more cynical and a lot angrier at what Britain had done to her youth during the depression and following the war.


















